So…we just had a huge pine fall (not sure which kind) during a horrible storm we had here in Western NC last night. I have a guy coming later today to remove it (several emergency calls worse than mine). It looks hollow inside (to some degree. My question is – I have another one just like it, just as tall near it. It’s leaning a little. Does it need to be removed? I love these trees – devastated to lose the one, would def hate to lose the other. The last pic is of the one still standing. Thanks!

by Argonaut411

34 Comments

  1. Johngalt20001

    ![gif](giphy|2ViZJi3RLXAZ22PG08)

    That fence:

  2. Inevitable_Sweet_624

    Take the fence panels down now before they are crushed. The other trees should be checked for rot and removed if they are positive for rot.

  3. Consistent_Worth_562

    spruce, not pine. do you know if budworm is a problem in your area? good news is that spruces smells nice and can make good firewood. have the person removing the downed tree assess the standing one to see if it should come down or not. if they can’t tell you, I’d sure hope they can refer someone who can.

  4. Squonkin-around

    What i love is that it appears the tree got hung up before it made contact with the fence. Beautiful.

  5. Civil_Huckleberry212

    Call back that fence company and let them use this for advertising. It’ll pay for the tree cleanup

  6. PNW_OlLady_2025

    Oh my, what an absolutely gorgeous fence. If I ever lived in a suburb again, you can bet your sweet bippy I’d be getting this or similar!

  7. kennycreatesthings

    literally slapped my hand to my face in shock and concern.

  8. E_rock_89

    That’s the luckiest fence alive, or er dead?

  9. hudsoncress

    I donno about the tree but that’s one hell of a fence

  10. sprantermitt

    May I have your fence contractor info? Want to build a border wall….

  11. browntown84

    That’s a nice fence. Be a shame if something fell on it.

  12. Illustrious_Chain_46

    Bro, what’s your fence made from. That builder is goat

  13. FreudianNip-Slip

    Can that tree be saved or is it a goner?

  14. cookeryandwookery

    Whoever built that fence deserves a raise.

  15. TheMightySaeed

    That fence must be made from the same type tree. Family reunion.

  16. MarsOnHigh

    Talk about inches from total annihilation

  17. vitaminalgas

    Remove that section of fence and cut away my guy

  18. Driftmoth

    Ask the guy who’s coming over to remove your tree about the other one.

  19. BigCATtrades

    Hire a crane and drop it over the fence to the other side and let the neighbors deal with it. It’s the American way!

  20. Select-Government-69

    Softwoods like that spruce just have weak wood and break easily. There was likely nothing structurally wrong with the tree. It’s not unusual for old trees to hollow and it has minimal impact on the structural integrity.

    I also had significant wind damage from last night. It was a hell of a storm.

    I have 6 trees just like that one in my front yard and 6 have had their tops broken by the wind sometime 0-20 years ago.

  21. ResistOk9038

    This seems like an excellent case for acoustic tomography on that tree that still stands

  22. Mysterious-Alps-5186

    Man a woodworker would love to salvage that!

  23. ArboristTreeClimber

    Tree looked healthy. Could be a high wind zone? Either way, sometimes these things happen for no reason. A big gust hits a tree at the right angle and…..boom. A healthy tree can even fall over on a calm and sunny day.

    Something to prevent this? Wind dampening. All those branches that were cut from the bottom to make it higher? Should have been left alone, they work to absorb the wind and prevent gust from hitting direct on the trunk. All the foliage on the top created a sail essentially which increase the captured force and caused failure.

  24. GenesisNemesis17

    Whoever built that fence would probably love these photos for their website. “We don’t just build fences, we build impenetrable walls.”

Pin