In Arizona. Staff said they are large lemons. I tasted it and it’s like a very muted flavor lemon a little sweet. Are they lemons?

by GreyAardvark

22 Comments

  1. Amesb34r

    I’ve never seen a lemon like that but I’m no lemonologist.

  2. mean-mommy-

    Maybe a Meyer lemon or some other hybrid? It’s hard to tell because the picture of the fruit is so weird.

  3. Ecodragon1022

    Is it maybe a pomelo? It’s hard to tell the size from the pictures

  4. ok-MTLmunchies

    If the staff is latino, they would refer to a lime as a lemon (límon)
    Looking at your 3rd picture though, that looks like a pomelo

  5. SnowOverRain

    The slice photo looks exactly like a pomelo, but ultimately we need a banana for scale, OP.

  6. MALDI2015

    There are certain grapefruit hybrids that were grown from seeds, resulting in undesirable traits.

    This often occurred because the original planter was unaware that citrus trees typically do not grow true to seed.

    When I was a child, I was surrounded by these types of citrus trees, and their fruit was very sour and bitter—nothing like the sweet, edible oranges that were intended.

  7. stellavangelist

    Depending on where you are in AZ, there could definitely be other citrus around that cross pollinated another tree that produced random seeds that became this tree. The city applies the whitewash intentionally so they also may have purchased an odd hybrid tree like that and planted it there. There’s a guy in Phoenix who runs an exotic fruit farm and has some citrus trees that have no names but have some of the most amazing citrus fruit I’ve ever tried. Edited to change phrasing – citrus trees don’t produce surprise fruit.

  8. soad334

    Colors are a little weird but theyre likely just a little unripe which makes sense given the time of year. the inside fruit screams grapefruit. I say this having had multiple grapefruit trees in Arizona over the years.

  9. KEYPiggy_YT

    They look like small pomelos. Probably a hybrid

  10. 95castles

    99% sure those are Limas. Boring flavor, I have a tree myself. Like super watered down orange/lemon juice

  11. International-Law-67

    Lemon orange hybrids. They’re not good

  12. BabyGottaEat

    I believe these are lemons. It’s just that the fruit has been left on the tree for an extended period of time. Back in 2010, I bought a house in LA with an overgrown, unkempt, lemon tree. A lot of the lemons were huge. The looked swollen like the lemons in OPs pic. It appeared the the fruit just kept growing and didn’t drop at the end of the season. I think some of those lemons were a few years old. They were sweet and the tartness had faded over time. Several of them were too dry on the inside like OPs. I was the caretaker of that tree for 6 years and the lemons appeared and tasted more like what you are used too over time. However, they were always sweeter than the store bought ones. I miss that tree every day. Anyway, it would be fun to harvest all of the fruit on the tree to spawn some new fruiting next season. The next ones will be amazing.

  13. Intelligent-Job-6407

    In Mexico those are called lima dulce or limon real. Citrus limettoides.

  14. tarlastar

    Yes they are lemons. Citrus grows amazingly well in Arizona. Wait until you get a navel orange the size of a softball.

Pin