1
Best Overall
Muck Boots Edgewater Tall Boot
Pros
Triple-layer toe for safety with garden toolsKnee-high for maximum protectionCons
Boots can be slippery on ice or snow
This garden boot covers all the bases for any serious gardener. The knee-high shaft offers optimum mud coverage, the toe and heel are reinforced with three layers of thick rubber, there’s a comfortable attached interior bootie with a breathable mesh lining, plus it has thick traction on the soles. Muck brings all the features you need in a messy outdoor environment into this boot.
A stretchy cuff hugs the calf, helping retain warmth while preventing dirt and debris from entering. Despite the extra traction on the outsole, they may still be slick on snow and ice.
Key SpecsMaterialRubberWeight2 lbHeightKnee high
2
Best Lined
L.L.Bean Light Wellie Boots, Pull-On
ProsFoam liner for sweat wicking and comfortGrippy outsole for maximum tractionConsLimited size run
These lightweight rain boots are engineered for functional performance in wet environments. The upper is constructed from durable waterproof rubber to prevent moisture from seeping in and there’s a recycled polyester lining.
They also have a polyurethane foam midsole for sweat wicking, extra comfort, and shock absorption, along with a grippy rubber outsole for traction on slick surfaces.
For convenience, the boots feature pull tabs, a flexible neoprene collar, and a stretch jersey binding for a secure fit around the ankle that also helps them slide on and off easily.
Key SpecsMaterialRubber, polyesterWeightNot listedHeightAnkle high
Advertisement – Continue Reading Below
3
Most Stylish
Hunter Original Short Rain Boots
ProsGreat for garden use and casual wearInsulated for warmth in below-freezing temperaturesConsPricier than other options without value added
These are my go-to rain boots. They’re made from natural rubber and assembled by hand. The shorter 11-inch shaft provides protection but doesn’t inhibit mobility.
The outsole features the Hunter Original tread pattern for good traction on soft or uneven ground and there’s a lining that adds comfort and helps manage moisture. Hunter also insulates all of its boots for maximum warmth during the colder months.
Key SpecsMaterialRubberWeight2.25 lbHeightCalf high
4
Best With Handles
Crocs Handle It Rain Boots
ProsHandles for easy removalComfortable foot bedConsRuns small
These rain boots are constructed from molded EVA, a lightweight, waterproof material that’s easy to wipe down if caked with mud and flexible enough for repeated bending and kneeling.
They’re said to be as comfortable as regular Crocs clogs though they’re designed to fit slightly snug, so we recommend sizing up and wearing thicker socks. The boots are available in four colors, including bright yellow and hot-pink.
Key SpecsMaterialEthylene vinyl acetateWeightNot listedHeightCalf high
Sarah Connor is a Reviews Editor for Popular Mechanics. She also contributes to Runner’s World, Bicycling, Best Products, and Biography.com. Before joining the Hearst Magazines team, Sarah was a National Content Editor for Hearst Television. She holds a master’s in Journalism from Syracuse University and a dual bachelor’s in English and Communications from the University of Pittsburgh. When she isn’t writing up a review of the newest gadgets, you can find her heading to the nearest rink for a figure skating session or enjoying the outdoors with her beloved Australian Shepherd, Rosie.
Watch Next
Advertisement – Continue Reading Below
Advertisement – Continue Reading Below
Advertisement – Continue Reading Below